National show helping in Sandusky County cold case - WTOC-TV: Savannah, Beaufort, SC, News, Weather & Sports

National show helping in Sandusky County cold case

Photos of Isabel Cordle and the crime scene. Photos of Isabel Cordle and the crime scene.
BELLEVUE, OH (Toledo News Now) -

For 25 years, a cold case in Sandusky County has gone unsolved. The murder of a local wife and mother has puzzled investigators, but now a national television show is shining a new light on her death.

Isabel Cordle was found dead at her home on West Main Street in Bellevue. Her murderer has not been found, but that could change now that the case has been reopened.

"A husband woke up in the early hours of January and found his wife had been murdered on the front couch in the living room," said Sandusky County Sheriff Kyle Overmyer.

Cordle was struck in the head with a hatchet. Pictures of the home-turned-crime scene have been pulled out of storage at the sheriff's office.

"I was only 14 years of age then," Overmyer said. "My father was working here as a deputy, as well, and he was one of the first responders on scene that day."

Producers of the TNT show "Cold Justice" reached out to the sheriff's office to help with the investigation. The show looks at unsolved murders in small towns across the country.

"I think a lot of times, like any investigation, people are reluctant to want to come forward initially and talk to the authorities, and provide them with that information we need to make a case," said Detective Sean O'Connell, from the Sandusky County Sheriff's Office. "Then, when time starts to lapse, people realize, ‘You know what? Maybe I should have done something that I didn't do back then that I need to do now.'"

The sheriff's office says the show has helped them dig deep, narrowing down a list of suspects from eight to one: Cordle's husband Richard, who married a coworker eight months after his wife's death.

The story of Isabel Cordle will air October 15 at 10 p.m. on TNT.

Mobile users, click on the "Video" button in the app to watch this story. Download our app here.

Copyright 2013 Toledo News Now. All rights reserved.

  • NewsNewsMore>>

  • Bulloch County vandals face felony charges

    Bulloch County vandals face felony charges

    Friday, January 19 2018 7:09 PM EST2018-01-20 00:09:24 GMT
    (Source: WTOC)(Source: WTOC)

    A few minutes of vandalism have two young people in trouble with the law after someone destroyed several mannequins and an inflatable at TMT Farms annual Christmas lights display

    More >>

    A few minutes of vandalism have two young people in trouble with the law after someone destroyed several mannequins and an inflatable at TMT Farms annual Christmas lights display

    More >>
  • Chatham County asks sheriff's office for help as demerger looms

    Chatham County asks sheriff's office for help as demerger looms

    Friday, January 19 2018 6:52 PM EST2018-01-19 23:52:31 GMT
    (Source: WTOC)(Source: WTOC)

    Chatham County leaders have decided against using the city of Savannah for police services in the unincorporated part of the county after February 1st. 

    Instead, they're asking the sheriff for help in a last-ditch effort to patrol that area. The sheriff says this is the first time they've asked for his help in the whole demerger process. 

    More >>

    Chatham County leaders have decided against using the city of Savannah for police services in the unincorporated part of the county after February 1st. 

    Instead, they're asking the sheriff for help in a last-ditch effort to patrol that area. The sheriff says this is the first time they've asked for his help in the whole demerger process. 

    More >>
  • Good News: McCoy Park dedication

    Good News: McCoy Park dedication

    Friday, January 19 2018 6:37 PM EST2018-01-19 23:37:06 GMT
    (Source: WTOC)(Source: WTOC)

    There was really no other name that would do for the park that was re-dedicated in the Marsh Bluff/Runaway Point community on Friday.

    Neighborhood leaders and members of the community gathered at what is now known as Retha Mae McCoy Community Park renamed for the woman who worked for nearly three decades to get children in the Runaway Point Community a place to play. 

    More >>

    There was really no other name that would do for the park that was re-dedicated in the Marsh Bluff/Runaway Point community on Friday.

    Neighborhood leaders and members of the community gathered at what is now known as Retha Mae McCoy Community Park renamed for the woman who worked for nearly three decades to get children in the Runaway Point Community a place to play. 

    More >>
Powered by Frankly